Review of ‘Original Sin’ by P D James

It has the familiar comforts of a P D James murder mystery – Dalgliesh is back in action aided by Kate and Aaron. Gore and murder is typical trademark style as the story races to a final climax.

Image Courtesy – Amazon com

And we learn more about the nature of publishing business and the human frailties abound as everywhere else.

Collection:Bloomberg Credit: Bloomberg via Getty Images Courtesy: Getty Images
Credit: Bloomberg via Getty Images
Courtesy: Getty Images

James does not even spare the familiar world of publishing and serves it to us, warts and all. Apart from the power politics that lies at the heart of many ‘family owned’ businesses, James pays a fitting tribute to the insecurities of even vintage writers who worry about losing their talent in a rapidly changing world.

James has mentioned elsewhere that a novelist must be able to stand aside from the experience, view it with detachment, however painful and fashion it into a satisfying shape. Perhaps it is also his ability to assume the role of a privileged spectator, the cold searching gaze which caused Graham Greene to write that every writer has a splinter of ice in the heart. So she paints a charming vignette about an ageing murder mystery writer whose loyal audience has aged along with her and their declining numbers are no longer being replaced by a younger audience. It is indeed a delightful ability of her to set the tale so unemotionally given that she herself is an ageing murder mystery writer. But no fears – we are sure that her popularity is transcending generations as it has done in the past.

Well the murder mystery is about the death of a publisher and the circle of suspects seems to be narrow and primarily within his own organization. James gives us a run down of varying motives and alibis. She puts in plenty of red herrings and throws us off the scent. The final dénouement is possibly not as satisfying as some of her novels but she does sum it up quite logically.

We get to see less of Dalgliesh as the action is run mostly around the suspects and his assistants. But couple of deft interviews are set up for us to savor. Dalgliesh is at his best when he manages to win the trust of a precocious child and one wonders how many of us could have handled the discussion with such finesse. And finally he assuaged the dilemma faced by her single mother, who happens to be a bar-dancer, by saying that the option of sending the child to a boarding school would certainly be a convenient one for her but need not be a wrong one for the child.

The characters have a lot of angst caused by their modern lifestyles and James gives us a bird’s-eye view on the disenchanted and disengaged youth, feminism, clash of personal anxieties against career ambitions, the mindless consumerism and trivialization of sacred relationships.

James has used the device of old sins casting long shadows to varying degrees in her other novels as well such as Shroud for a Nightingale, A Certain Justice, Devices and Desires etc. And in this book she has chosen to use it as a theme by naming the book, ‘Original Sin’.


2 Replies to “Review of ‘Original Sin’ by P D James”

  1. I have read every PD James Book and also every book by her friend Ruth Rendell. I am attempting to write my own version of a PD James/Ruth Rendell style detective book. How fortuitous that I came across your blog as none of my acquaintances share my obsession. My favourite PD James story is Innocent Blood. Devices and Desires is also fantastic.


    1. Hi,
      Thanks for dropping by – I share your excitement in discovering a P D James fan ( read a few books by Ruth Rendell during my college days but I do plan to read them as well).
      Am fascinated with her work as she gives a running commentary on modern day life and its challenges, her shrewd assessment of our trials and tribulations that can be countered only through a stoic and positive approach.
      Also her characters are complex and well drawn though she does run a few pet themes. And the mysteries are tantalizing as well – talk about the icing on the Cake.
      Am writing reviews on all her novels and have done about half a dozen so far. All the best for your novel. And do keep reading.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.